When does woodcutting earn more than fletching?
In the Melvor Idle 2 Demo, start with 60,000 arrow shafts and 3,600 feathers. Making Headless Arrows uses the last feather after two hours and adds 21,600 GP in net sale value. Cutting Normal Trees catches up at six hours.
Net GP gained at Demo base rates, with one activity and no restocking| Time away | Headless Arrows | Normal Logs |
| 4 hours | 21,600 GP | 14,400 GP |
| 6 hours | 21,600 GP | 21,600 GP |
| 8 hours | 21,600 GP | 28,800 GP |
|---|
Net GP deducts the sale value of the ingredients used. It assumes you sell the output when you return. Headless Arrows recipe · Normal Log sale value
How the Demo calculation works
¹ Net gain is the new items’ sale price minus the sale value of ingredients you use. Selling is a separate action when you return. Headless Arrows use 10 shafts and 1 feather every 2 seconds for 10 arrows. Shafts sell for 0 GP, feathers for 4 GP and a finished arrow for 1 GP. A Normal Tree gives one 3 GP log every 3 seconds.
The model counts whole actions from a fresh start, caps Demo replay at 24 hours and assumes bank space, no bonuses, rare drops or manual switching. The 8-hour example was checked against Demo tools. Early Access rates await verification.